(1) 2 3 4 ... 9 »
Goldy Goldy
  • Forum Manager
  • Forum Manager
  • Joined: 10/3/2004 21:05
  • From Cheshire
  • Group: Registered Users Image Admin Caresheets Moderators Advisers
  • Posts: 16771
  • Posted on: 2/11/2004 12:23
Cycling and how to avoid New Tank Syndrome - by Alien Anna #1
You may think fish keeping is about fish, but actually it's about bacteria.

New Tank Syndrome

For a lot of people, their fish keeping experience starts like this:

They buy a tank, a stand, a filter, a hood, lights, selection of plants, rocks, diver with genuine bubbles... They add water (which they have carefully dechlorinated and got up to temperature). And then they make their first (and biggest) mistake: they buy some fish. This might be a week later, but apart from checking the tank isn't leaking and all the gizmo's are working, leaving the tank to stand for a week doesn't accomplish much.

The problem is ammonia: Fish pee ammonia. Not only that, but their poop also breaks down to ammonia. So before long, your new fish are swimming about in a toxic pool of ammonia.

Tragically, ammonia is deadly poisonous to fish. It inhibits their breathing, rather as carbon monoxide does in humans, and they slowly start to suffocate. Don't believe anyone who says there's a "safe" level of ammonia for fish - I'm sure there's a safe level of carbon monoxide, but I'm not going to rent a house that has it!

Beneficial Bacteria

This is where your bacteria come in: fortunately, certain types of bacteria can break down ammonia into a less toxic substance called nitrite (that's with an 'i' - note the spelling, it's important) aka NO2-. After a few days, this "ammonia-eating" bacteria start to grow in your tank, particularly your filter and gravel, and drop your ammonia levels to zero. Phew!

But your fish aren't home and dry: nitrite is less toxic than ammonia, but is still toxic and can still kill fish. Thankfully, another sort of bacteria starts to grow in your filter and gravel (albeit a little more slowly than the "ammonia eating" bacteria). This beneficial bacteria breaks down nitrite (NO2-) and turns it into nitrate (NO3+) - note the 'a'. Nitrate is only harmful in quite high levels, which can be controlled by regular partial water changes, and is useful to aquatic plants as a fertiliser.

This process is called the Nitrogen Cycle, and in fish-keepers jargon, a tank where the bacteria are happily munching on ammonia and nitrite is said to be "cycled". In summary:

Fish waste --> ammonia --> nitrite --> nitrate, which plants use to grow.

The beneficial bacteria are what make your tank safe for fish. Although present in the water, they are largely found in the gravel or sand in the bottom of your tank and in the filter. As well as ammonia, they require a good source of oxygenated water to grow.

How to "Cycle" Your New Tank

Traditionally, the way of getting around this problem of establishing the beneficial bacteria is to put just a couple of really tough fish in your new tank and wait 8 weeks before adding a few more fish.

Unfortunately, even if the fish survive (which is a pretty big "if" ) they have to endure weeks and weeks of first ammonia poisoning and then nitrite poisoning. They may survive, but they may never enjoy good health or live as long as they should and I personally feel it's a welfare issue.

But there is a better way: Fish-less Cycling. If you follow this link,http://www.fishkeeping.co.uk/articles ... hless-cycling-article.htm

The advantage to Fish-less Cycling is that it effectively grows your bacteria before any fish are damaged. By the time your ammonia and nitrite readings are zero you'll have plenty of beneficial bacteria to break down the waste from as many fish as you want in your tank and can fit.

Can a Cycled Tank UnCycle Again?

Even in an established tank you can get ammonia or nitrite "spikes", usually because something has killed off your beneficial bacteria. This could be for several reasons:

1. You forgot to dechlorinate your water when you did a water change. Chlorine kills bacteria!

2. You over-cleaned your tank, particularly the filter media and gravel, particularly is you didn't dechlorinate your water and particularly if the gravel or filter were out of the water a long time.

3. Some filter companies recommend you change the filter media every month (Well they would say that, wouldn't they??? ). Not only is this an expensive waste of time quite often (filter sponges usually just need a rinse in some old tank water), you could be removing the beneficial bacteria. If you want to replace a filter insert, leave the sponge or floss in the tank for a week or so beforehand.

4. A power-outage stopped your filter or pump from working for a couple of hours (bacteria need oxygenated water to survive).

5. You over-loaded the bacteria in your tank's ability to break down the fish waste, for instance by suddenly over-stocking your tank, particularly with messy fish.

6. A tub of food has fallen into the tank and gone bad, thus overloading the beneficial bacteria's ability to cope.

How to Save the Day (and the Fish) with an Un-Cycled Tank

OK, so you didn't do Fishless Cycling or you did scrub out your matured tank and now your fish are dying and nothings breaking down that ammonia and nitrite. What do you do now?

Here's what I do to give my fish the best chance:
1. Immediately do a 10-15% water change with dechlorinated water and continue to do this at least once daily until your tank is cycling (i.e. ammonia and nitrite are at zero).

2. Test the water daily for ammonia and nitrite until the values are holding at zero for several days running. If levels are high, do an immediate, extra water change.

3. If at all possible, get some matured filter media and/or gravel from a matured tank and put it in your tank, suspended in an old stocking. This will hopefully impregnate your new tank with the beneficial bacteria. One lady successfully used floss from a relative's fish pond to colonise her new tank! (you have to be careful that what you use is clean and free from pathogens, of course).

4. Keep good aeration in the tank both to help the fish a little and to oxygenate those beneficial bacteria.

5. Avoid using medications, if at all possible, as many medications kill off beneficial bacteria. Your fish may well get ick, fungus or other infections due to the stress of the ammonia and nitrite but the priority is to get that water quality as good as possible.

6. If you have delicate fish in the tank, such as plecos, corys or other bottom dwellers, tetras, pencil fish etc. try to re-home them temporarily, such as asking the Local Fish Shop to look after them until your tank is cycled (after all, chances are that they got you in this mess in the first place).

7. Live plants can directly use ammonia, so if you can, put some cheap aquatic plants in the tank, such as elodea or giant vallis.

8. Don't feed your fish at all if your ammonia readings are high, and only feed bare minimum rations every other day, until the tank cycles. This will cut down on the ammonia the fish produce. Since fish are cold blooded creatures and don't need the calories of a mammal they can go several days without food anyway, and the occasional fast is good for them. Your fish may not be very hungry anyway so do be careful not to feed more than the fish can eat and clean up uneaten food immediately, before it rots and produces even more ammonia.

9. Only clean the gravel superficially, of obvious dirt and uneaten food. You want the bacteria to colonise it and actually start to grow. Also, don't swap out your filter at this point - if it gets blocked, just clean it enough to unblock it, in used tank water.

Frequently Asked Questions on New Tanks and Cycling

Why didn't my Local Fish Shop (LFS) tell me any of this?

Good question. Probably ignorance - people are amazingly ignorant of the Nitrogen Cycle, which is shocking when you consider its importance. IMHO, more people have killed more fish due to bad advice from an LFS than anything else. Temperature and pH are most often blamed when ammonia and nitrite are by far the more significant problems. When it comes to buying fish and aquarium products: Trust No One. Double-check everything you are told and plan in advance.

The guy at the LFS sold me some "Instant Cycle" product that contains the beneficial bacteria. Do I still need to cycle my tank?

There are a variety of bacteria products on the market which claim to be able to increase the speed at which your tank cycles (note: none of them claim instant cycling, whatever LFS employees may say). Personally I can't see how they could work, since the bacteria require a source of ammonia and oxygenated water, but even if they can be held in some sort of "suspended animation", that still doesn't get around the fact that they can't instantly colonise your gravel and filter. Colonisation takes time!

The LFS sold me a product that locks away ammonia. Can I use that to save my fish?

That's a difficult one. Ammonia is deadly to fish and you want it out of your water ASAP. However, products that lock away ammonia have some major disadvantages: For a start, they mess up your water test readings so either look negative when they aren't, or look terrible when they aren't so bad. Secondly, if the beneficial bacteria still aren't established, and the ammonia from fish keeps rising, it could over-shoot the ability of the product to lock it away and you get a sudden (and deadly) ammonia spike (which of course you can't reliably test for). Thirdly, theoretically, "locked" ammonia can't be utilised by the beneficial bacteria and may possibly retard its growth.

Why did my pleco die while my gouramis and danios were fine?

There is a big difference between "alive" and "fine", but even so, the reason that your pleco died is probably because he was less able to get to the top of the tank where the oxygen levels are highest and the ammonia levels a little lower. Danios swim near the top of the water and are famous for their survival ability (I believe they used them in nuclear experiments in the 50s). Gouramis and bettas can directly breath air, through their labyrinth organ.

The LFS guys said he'd never heard of this "Fishless Cycling" nonsense and he's been in fish-keeping for 40 years. He said to cycle with danios. How come?

Fishless Cycling is a relatively new technique that has only really been talked about since the age of the Internet. It is a lot safer for fish and avoids suffering. It also prevents fish being subtley damaged in a way that may affect their health for life. However, people may be tempted to stick to what they know "works", possibly not really understanding the welfare implications, or the great advantages to cycling fishless.

I have a betta in a fish bowl. Can I cycle without a filter?

You certainly can (and should). Just follow the same procedure as for a larger tank - the bacteria should colonise your gravel. Since the bacteria really need oxygen to do well, adding an air-pump with an air-stone, or better yet, a small tank filter of some kind, will improve things even further.

But my biggest problem is that algae that's taken over my tank!

Algae in an un-cycled tank is a trivial cosmetic problem that you should worry about later. Algae doesn't kill fish - but algae can directly use ammonia, which is probably why algae-covered tanks are assumed to be unhealthy tanks.

But I tested my water when I first set my tank up and it was fine!

You won't get ammonia or nitrite unless you have fish, or an artificial source of ammonia (such as that you add during fishless cycling).

Won't carbon in my filter remove all the toxins anyway?

Carbon may temporarily remove some of the ammonia, but it won't touch nitrite and only works a few days anyway, and then everything can leach back into the tank again! There are no short cuts to growing beneficial bacteria (other than using a matured filter and gravel) to cycling your tank.

But it's so boring waiting for my tank to cycle. Can't I just add a couple of fish now?

If you are impatient just remember that it's even less fun watching fish die. So spend your time designing your "aqua-scape", soaking your bogwood and rocks, establishing your plants and checking that everything works fine. Also, get on the Internet and read up about the species you'd like to get, checking with your LFS's to see what they have in stock. Buying online is often cheaper and more convenient, so get to know your favourite outlets now.

UPDATE: We have an article on this as well here: http://www.fishkeeping.co.uk/articles ... ammonia-nitrite-spike.htm
Hero69 Hero69
  • Home away from home
  • Home away from home
  • Joined: 27/12/2004 21:22
  • From West Midlands
  • Group: Registered Users Basic Membership
  • Posts: 177
  • Posted on: 15/1/2005 16:14
Re: Cycling and how to avoid New Tank Syndrome - by Alien Anna #2

That was a big posting, but well worth it.
  • Just can't stay away
  • Just can't stay away
  • Joined: 23/1/2005 16:18
  • From Somerset
  • Group: Registered Users Basic Membership
  • Posts: 88
  • Posted on: 15/3/2005 17:56
Re: Cycling and how to avoid New Tank Syndrome - by Alien Anna #3
This should be printed out in large letters and displayed in all aquatic dealers. I'm fed up with hearing about unnecessary fish disasters. Today i was down at my lfs buying a pair of panchax. I stared at the tank for ages trying to select the best female, then a woman next to me, whilst looking in the next tank on said: " i'll av one of them, one of them, and i'll ave two of them. Her selection was not compatible with eachother, so i pointed this out to her, and she admitted that she had only been keeping fish since christmas, and that she loved her fish but had lost alot. I asked did you cycle your tank properly?, goldy, she did'nt have a clue what i was talking about. Good post goldy good post. David.
The main things in my life are my wife, my fish, my dogs, my guitars, and......mother earth.
Re: Cycling and how to avoid New Tank Syndrome - by Alien Anna #4
you come across it all the time david, such a shame for the fish, only yesterday someone emailed me for some apple snails and i told her the price etc, she said i'll have 4 or whatever, she also said below is a list of my tank and its inhabitants, only had clown loaches, although im desperate to give some of my snails new homes i wont sign their death warrents, rather keep em.

Goldy Goldy
  • Forum Manager
  • Forum Manager
  • Joined: 10/3/2004 21:05
  • From Cheshire
  • Group: Registered Users Image Admin Caresheets Moderators Advisers
  • Posts: 16771
  • Posted on: 23/3/2005 14:52
Re: Cycling and how to avoid New Tank Syndrome - by Alien Anna #5
Its sad to think so many fish keepers don't even know the basics Did you tell her Di that clown loach eat snails I take it you did
Re: Cycling and how to avoid New Tank Syndrome - by Alien Anna #6
yes i said i could'nt sell them to her, i do know several people that have brought and ive later found out they have clown loaches, di
cherylanne cherylanne
  • Just popping in
  • Just popping in
  • Joined: 6/4/2005 19:29
  • From Surrey
  • Group: Registered Users Basic Membership
  • Posts: 7
  • Posted on: 6/4/2005 20:47
Re: Cycling and how to avoid New Tank Syndrome - by Alien Anna #7
This is an incredible article and has taught me so much. Such a shame I never came across it before I took up fish keeping six weeks ago. I have printed it out so I can refer to it while cycling my tank because I have 'new tank syndrome' and am now trying my hardest to adjust everything. This reads like a bible to me! Thank you
chloe chloe
  • Home away from home
  • Home away from home
  • Joined: 29/7/2004 13:47
  • From -
  • Group: Registered Users Basic Membership
  • Posts: 532
  • Posted on: 6/4/2005 21:01
Re: Cycling and how to avoid New Tank Syndrome - by Alien Anna #8
We've all been there cherylanne!
sadie sadie
  • Home away from home
  • Home away from home
  • Joined: 24/2/2005 20:23
  • From Lancashire
  • Group: Registered Users Basic Membership
  • Posts: 850
  • Posted on: 2/5/2005 23:05
Re: Cycling and how to avoid New Tank Syndrome - by Alien Anna #9
I have just got a new tank and want to cycle it before I put my fish in, at the moment they are in a very small tank which I can not gat the nitrite level down I think becouse of the size of tank (11 litres 2 fantails) I did not cycle this tank becouse of ignorance but I want to get it right this time when it is cycled how do I transfer the fish do I put them in a plastic bag as if I had just bought them and float them in the water until they climatize
Euryale Euryale
  • Brackish Moderator
  • Brackish Moderator
  • Joined: 26/1/2005 9:06
  • From Essex
  • Group: Registered Users
  • Posts: 1237
  • Posted on: 3/5/2005 8:12
Re: Cycling and how to avoid New Tank Syndrome - by Alien Anna #10

sadie wrote:
when it is cycled how do I transfer the fish do I put them in a plastic bag as if I had just bought them and float them in the water until they climatize

Yeah that will be fine Sadie. You can add a little tank water to the bag every now and then as they are floating too.
Resized Image