Betta's and melafix! |
||
|---|---|---|
Posted on: 4/7/2012 18:32 |
||
 Joined:
22/4/2011 20:33 From: Oxfordshire
Group:
Registered Users Basic Membership Posts: 207
|
Hi guys just a quick question is it safe to use melafix on betta's and paradise fish?
Only reason i ask as i was chatting to someone today and they told me that it can damage there labarinth organ. Thanks lisa |
|
| _________________
The day you stop caring is the day you should stop keeping any pet whether fur or fins! |
||
Re: Betta's and melafix! |
||
|---|---|---|
Posted on: 4/7/2012 19:26 |
||
  Joined:
6/7/2010 19:26 From: Worcestershire
Group:
Registered Users Image Admin Caresheets Moderators Advisers FK Supporter Posts: 9663
|
This is so far purely anecdotal and there is no scientific evidence for any such effect.
Anna Robinson, from Mars Fishcare, posted this in response to a previous question about this: Quote:
I have personally used Melafix to treat Honey Gouramis who are also labyrinth fish in the past and had no issues, but if you're worried you could use a different treatment. If you're looking for a good anti-bacterial which is very safe, try eSHa 2000, but that said, Melafix ought to be fine. |
|
| _________________
 |
||
Re: Betta's and melafix! |
||
|---|---|---|
Posted on: 4/7/2012 19:37 |
||
|
Joined:
22/4/2011 20:33 From: Oxfordshire
Group:
Registered Users Basic Membership Posts: 207
|
Thanks for clearing that up fishlady good to know these things just in case.
I always keep a bottle of myxazin, esha exit and 2000 in my fishy first aid kit just in case as you never know what they may throw at you so best to be prepared  |
|
| _________________
The day you stop caring is the day you should stop keeping any pet whether fur or fins! |
||
Re: Betta's and melafix! |
||
|---|---|---|
Posted on: 4/7/2012 19:47 |
||
|
Joined:
6/7/2010 19:26 From: Worcestershire
Group:
Registered Users Image Admin Caresheets Moderators Advisers FK Supporter Posts: 9663
|
Likewise - I think I keep more fishy first aid items in the house than human ones
 |
|
| _________________
|
||
Re: Betta's and melafix! |
||
|---|---|---|
Posted on: 4/7/2012 22:03 |
||
  Joined:
22/11/2008 17:42 From: West Yorkshire
Group:
Registered Users Caresheets Advisers FK Supporter Deep End Posts: 6497
|
As FL said, this is just a fish keeping myth that keeps doing the rounds
 Seems someone lost an ill Betta after treatment and blamed the treatment, when actually the fish was simply too far gone to rescue. Seems to have snow balled from there. I've used Melafix with a Betta and he was fine. As the labyrinth organ takes in air from the surface it is not affected by anything in the water. |
|
| _________________
Please fill in your personal profile if you are posting on FK. This saves so much time and unnecessary questions so it helps everyone here The importance of QT when adding new fish to an existing tank, to avoid losses (and tears): http://www.fishkeeping.co.uk/articles_84/fishkeeping_quarantine.htm |
||
Re: Betta's and melafix! |
||
|---|---|---|
Posted on: 5/7/2012 6:33 |
||
|
Joined:
22/4/2011 20:33 From: Oxfordshire
Group:
Registered Users Basic Membership Posts: 207
|
Thank you ladies i knew i'd get a right answer on here.
Have to say i do prefer melafix as i love the smell of it. Thanks again Lisa |
|
| _________________
The day you stop caring is the day you should stop keeping any pet whether fur or fins! |
||
| Forum Jump: | Search in General Information |
|---|---|
