Welcome to FK. Please register to join  
 
Login
Username:

Password:


Lost Password?

Register now!
Main Menu
Adverfishments
about protozin
Posted on: 9/7/2012 19:21
Joined:
10/5/2012 20:52
From: Devon
Group:
Registered Users
Basic Membership
Posts: 167
im slowly building up my medications for the fish tank.i recently bought a bottle of protozin and when reading it,amongst others it is harmful for snails?can anyone tell me what the danger is? i only have 4 assassin snails in the tank to keep the pest snails down,what would be the routine for keeping the assassins if i had to medicate?and dont shoot me for saying this,but if it is a danger to snails,wouldnt it be an idea to use it to wipe out a snail infestation? not that i would....just curious.


Re: about protozin
Posted on: 9/7/2012 19:52
Joined:
6/7/2010 19:26
From: Worcestershire
Group:
Registered Users
Image Admin
Caresheets
Moderators
Advisers
FK Supporter
Posts: 9556
Many meds are dangerous for invertebrates (shrimps etc as well as snails), and some fish are sensitive to the same chemicals that cause problems for inverts, usually copper in this case in the form of Malachite Green. Protozin also contains formaldehyde which is risky for certain scaleless fish.

Using meds unnecessarily because a side-effect is that they are toxic to nuisance tank inhabitants is a bad idea. You might just as well use a chemical snail killer (similar ingredients), which we wouldn't recommend due to the risk to fish.

In general chemicals of any kind are best avoided and meds only used when necessary and when a clear diagnosis has shown the most suitable med to use. Exposure to meds is always to some extent risky for all tank inhabitants, and using meds where there is no symptomatic illness may allow the pathogens it's meant to treat to develop resistance, causing problems further down the line. A bit like the way that humans insisting on anti-biotics for viral problems that can't be treated with them, or not finishing the course, has lead to the bacteria they can treat developing resistance.

EDIT: If you had to use a med that snails are sensitive to and needed to treat the whole tank, you would have to remove the snails during treatment.

_________________

Re: about protozin
Posted on: 9/7/2012 20:34
Joined:
10/5/2012 20:52
From: Devon
Group:
Registered Users
Basic Membership
Posts: 167
as always,thanks for the info FL






Forum Jump:Search in General Information

[Advanced Search]


Who's Online
18 user(s) are online (11 user(s) are browsing Forums)

Members: 0
Guests: 18

more...
Adverts
LFS Shops
GreenAcres Water Garden Centre
All pond, tropical and marine products. Dyed Fish Campaign Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association
see listing...
Wavertree Nook Aquarium Centre
Wavertree Nook Aquarium Centre Suppliers Of Marine/Tropical/Cold Water Fish And Accessories
Variety of offers, check website for deals
see listing...
Big Fish Campaign
Big Fish Campaign
Volume Calculator
Tank Capacity Length

Width

Height

CMs Inches

Litres

UK Gallons
Unit Converter
Volume Litres

UK Gallons

US Gallons
Temperature Celsius

Fahrenheit
Length Centimetres

Inches

Feet

Metres
Top Posters

Goldy
16544

cathie
10895
Fishy-Fishy 9605

Fishlady
9556

suey2
9447

EagleC
8176

violet
6473

Coralline
5368

TetraLinz
4653

Goldnugget
4183
0.19 Seconds | 1 Queries