Welcome to FK. Please register to join  
 
Login
Username:

Password:


Lost Password?

Register now!
Main Menu
Adverfishments
Magic Sand - safe for aquariums?
Posted on: 24/9/2005 14:25
Joined:
29/8/2005 12:07
From: West Midlands
Group:
Registered Users
Basic Membership
Posts: 843
Im not sure if I have asked this on here yet or not, but does anyone know if Magic sand is safe for aquariums?
It is a hydrophobic sand that you can create amazing colourful structures in water, it would look amazing in a tank as you can create gravity defying structures in brilliant colours.

If anyone has any information on it It would be brilliant as id love to see it in my tank :)


Re: Magic Sand - safe for aquariums?
Posted on: 24/9/2005 14:41
Joined:
26/1/2005 9:06
From: Essex
Group:
Registered Users
Posts: 1238
I use to play with that stuff as a kid

Unsure really - its heavily dyed so I dont think id risk it plus the fact you never see it for sale in fish shops and I would have thought someone would have latched onto the idea if it was safe.

_________________

Re: Magic Sand - safe for aquariums?
Posted on: 24/9/2005 14:45
Joined:
29/8/2005 12:07
From: West Midlands
Group:
Registered Users
Basic Membership
Posts: 843
its a shame, i have read a lot into it and it does say that the coating comes off and it eventually returns to normal sand, question is what happens to the coating?



Re: Magic Sand - safe for aquariums?
Posted on: 24/9/2005 14:49
Joined:
26/1/2005 9:06
From: Essex
Group:
Registered Users
Posts: 1238
Exactly, it obviously seeps into the water-the colour and whatever it is that makes it sticky and hold its shape

_________________

Re: Magic Sand - safe for aquariums?
Posted on: 24/9/2005 15:18
Joined:
29/8/2005 12:07
From: West Midlands
Group:
Registered Users
Basic Membership
Posts: 843
im tempted to buy some and just keep it in water for about 6 months to see the effect then test the water to see what its leached.


Re: Magic Sand - safe for aquariums?
Posted on: 24/9/2005 17:15
Joined:
26/1/2005 9:06
From: Essex
Group:
Registered Users
Posts: 1238
How will you know what to test for though?
Regular aquarium test kits will only tell you if its effected the PH and stuff - it may well leak something toxic to fish that the tests are not designed to pick up

The other thing is magic sand when wet clumps and sticks together so if your fish got a mouthfull of it its like a lump or clot of sand not just grains that s/he can spit out - I just cant see it being a good thing.

_________________

Re: Magic Sand - safe for aquariums?
Posted on: 24/9/2005 23:47
Joined:
30/8/2004 12:51
From: -
Group:
Registered Users
Moderators
Advisers
FK Supporter
Deep End
Posts: 9605
Sounds like a bad idea to me. I would stick to gravel for freshwater, you can't go far wrong. I only put stuff in my tank if I buy it at my LFS, I trust them :)


Re: Magic Sand - safe for aquariums?
Posted on: 25/9/2005 0:39
Joined:
29/8/2005 12:51
From:
Group:
Registered Users
Basic Membership
Posts: 109
Hmmm not sure in this one....could be a good idea but me myself wouldnt be going down that road without the go ahead from my lfs.....will be nice to see the outcome from your test though? could spread some light over the subject and maybe catch on if all goes well......good luck and i like the idea

Ollie.


Re: Magic Sand - safe for aquariums?
Posted on: 25/9/2005 13:10
Joined:
29/8/2005 12:07
From: West Midlands
Group:
Registered Users
Basic Membership
Posts: 843
yeah good point - ah well - might get some plastic fish ;)


Re: Magic Sand - safe for aquariums?
Posted on: 26/9/2005 18:26
Profile
Guest
i personally wouldn't try it. beter the fishes health than an amzing tank.






Forum Jump:Search in General Information

[Advanced Search]


Who's Online
26 user(s) are online (15 user(s) are browsing Forums)

Members: 0
Guests: 26

more...
Adverts
LFS Shops
GreenAcres Water Garden Centre
All pond, tropical and marine products. Dyed Fish Campaign Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association
see listing...
Wavertree Nook Aquarium Centre
Wavertree Nook Aquarium Centre Suppliers Of Marine/Tropical/Cold Water Fish And Accessories
Variety of offers, check website for deals
see listing...
Big Fish Campaign
Big Fish Campaign
Volume Calculator
Tank Capacity Length

Width

Height

CMs Inches

Litres

UK Gallons
Unit Converter
Volume Litres

UK Gallons

US Gallons
Temperature Celsius

Fahrenheit
Length Centimetres

Inches

Feet

Metres
Top Posters

Goldy
16708

Fishlady
11405

cathie
11298

suey2
10088
Fishy-Fishy 9605

EagleC
8176

Violet
7212

Coralline
5730

TetraLinz
4655

Goldnugget
4183
0.203 Seconds | 1 Queries